Regardless,
all versions of the album include a lost soul classic: Bobby Powell's "The
Bells." It's a stately, yearning ballad, with the obscure Mr. Powell haunted
by a persistent ringing in his head (the name of the original single's b-side was
actually "Bing Bong"). The problem is, "The Bells" isn't really
a Christmas song at all - those are wedding (not Christmas) bells!
By the way,
"The Bells" sounds supiciously similar to an even more obscure, earlier holiday
platter, the Motivations' lovely "Christmas
Spirit" (1970). Perhaps there's a relationship there? We'll probably never
know....
In the end, however, either the Fuel or Paula discs will yield rewards for soul
freaks and Christmas geeks, though neither is entirely perfect. The Fuel disc is
mastered better, more thoughtfully (if incompletely) annotated, and easier to find
(distributed by Varese Sarabande through Universal). But, it focuses on the earlier,
more traditional material (to the exclusion of standouts like "Black Christmas"),
and it includes a mere baker's dozen tracks. The Paula package swells to nearly
double that size - 23 tracks, some of them indisputably essential. You be the judge,
I bought both....
Consumers Note. Jewel/Paula released a third variation
of Merry
Christmas Baby in 1996 - same title, new cover, fewer songs - on their Ronn
label. For their part, Fuel repackaged their Merry
Christmas Baby in 2005 - same songs, similar cover, but new title (Greatest
Christmas Hits). Plus, there's an entirely different series of rhythm & blues
Christmas albums called Merry Christmas Baby,
culled from the catalog of the Swing Time, King, and Hollywood family of labels
(read more) - albums which also prominently feature Charles
Brown. Confused yet? [top of page]